top of page

I Never Wanted to Choose

Writer: Martha Her
Martha Her
Jul 20
6 min read

Grieving a friendship, protecting a relationship, and learning that boundaries do not erase love.

Last October, I lost my best friend.

She did not die. Our friendship did—or perhaps it changed so dramatically that I no longer knew what to call it.

There are plenty of songs, movies, books, and dramatic TikTok videos about romantic heartbreak. But no one prepares you for the strange grief of losing a friendship with someone who is still very much alive. Someone you still care about. Someone you could technically call, but no longer know how to reach.

We had been friends for about seven years. Our friendship began with one of those slightly ridiculous stories that somehow becomes part of your personal history: a party, beer, and long, nonsense conversations that probably sounded much wiser at two in the morning than they actually were.

Before long, she became family.

Before the distance, before the hurt, there was laughter—and that beautiful part of the story will always be real.
Before the distance, before the hurt, there was laughter—and that beautiful part of the story will always be real.

Our friendship was not perfect. There had been a period when she entered a serious relationship and almost completely disappeared from my life. I felt abandoned then, although I eventually accepted it. During those years, life also took me through some of its darkest places. I struggled with my children, went through a divorce, made mistakes, and experienced moments when I genuinely believe God protected me from decisions that could have changed my life forever.

When my friend and I eventually reconnected, it felt as though we had found our way back home. We laughed until our stomachs hurt. We talked about everything. We supported one another through difficult moments and shared the kind of closeness that felt more like sisterhood than friendship.

Partying was often part of our time together. We met at bars, went to concerts, and sometimes drank far more than either of us needed to. At the time, it felt like freedom, laughter, and friendship. Looking back, I can also see that some of our bond had become connected to a lifestyle that could not continue forever.

Then I fell in love.

Falling in love changes the architecture of your life. Suddenly, your time, routines, priorities, and even your definition of home begin to shift. That does not mean your friends become unimportant, but the relationship cannot always remain exactly as it was.

My partner made sincere efforts to include my friend. He welcomed her into his home, drove us to concerts, and helped during evenings when partying made things more complicated than they needed to be. I also tried to preserve the friendship and make time for her.

Still, something had changed.

My friend may have felt that she was being replaced. My partner sometimes felt that the friendship—and the lifestyle surrounding it—was interfering with our relationship. And I stood in the middle, desperately wanting everyone to understand that loving one person did not mean I had stopped loving the other, because I cared for them in different ways .

But each of us was experiencing the situation through a different emotional lens.

Last fall, my friend went through crisis with serious consequences. During the most difficult weeks, I became the person trying to hold everything together. I communicated with people who needed information, helped with practical arrangements, cared for things at home, and tried to solve every new problem that appeared.

I did it because she was my best friend. I also became overwhelmed.

For several weeks, I neglected my work, my children, my relationship, and my own emotional health. My partner was not always comfortable with it, but he understood that my friend was in crisis and gave me room to help.

Once the immediate emergency had passed, I stepped back. I believed she was finally safe enough to begin managing the rest of the situation herself.

She experienced that step back as abandonment.

I experienced her reaction as though everything I had already done had been erased.

That was probably the moment our friendship truly fractured. She was hurting and needed more from me. I was exhausted and felt that I had already given more than I could sustain. Neither of us felt seen by the other.

Hurt soon turned into sarcasm, defensive messages, and distance. She made comments about my quieter life with my partner, joking that we had become boring. Perhaps humor was her way of expressing pain. At the time, however, the comments felt like criticism of the life I was trying to build.

Sometimes the answer is not to stop caring, but to stand still long enough to understand how a friendship must evolve.
Sometimes the answer is not to stop caring, but to stand still long enough to understand how a friendship must evolve.

Meanwhile, my partner and I began arguing about the friendship. He worried that the situation was damaging our relationship. I felt that he did not fully understand the depth of the bond or the grief I was experiencing.

The intensity of my friendship had been misunderstood by people before, and some of those misunderstandings eventually entered my romantic relationship. That hurt. I wanted my partner to trust me, but I also wanted to understand why the situation made him uncomfortable.

During one terrible argument, everything exploded. For a few painful hours, it appeared that I might lose both my relationship and my friendship at the same time.

Thankfully, my partner and I found our way back to each other. But the experience left him more protective of our relationship and left me feeling as though I had to choose between two people I love in very different ways.

The truth is that I never wanted to choose.

I wanted my friend to understand that building a life with someone did not mean I had stopped loving her. I wanted my partner to understand that grieving a friendship did not mean I loved him any less.

And I wanted everyone—including myself—to stop turning love into a competition.

My friend and I have exchanged only a few messages since then. Some have been painful. She still believes I abandoned her. I still believe I reached a point where continuing to rescue her would have required abandoning myself and the other people I love.

Some absences do not mean the love is gone. They simply leave an empty place where a beautiful chapter once sat.
Some absences do not mean the love is gone. They simply leave an empty place where a beautiful chapter once sat.

Perhaps both feelings can exist at the same time. She can genuinely feel abandoned even though abandoning her was never my intention. I can genuinely love her while also recognizing that I could no longer carry every part of her life situations.

I have often wanted to respond and explain everything one more time. But our conversations had begun to feel like a courtroom in which we each presented evidence proving that the other person was guilty.

I spend enough time in courtrooms for my job. I do not want to build one inside my heart.

So, I asked the Holy Spirit what I should say.

The answer seemed to be silence.

Not the angry silence we use to punish someone. Not the manipulative silence that says, “Now you will see how much you need me.” It felt more like a sacred pause—a space in which neither of us had to keep defending ourselves or reopening the wound.

Sometimes silence does not mean we have stopped caring. Sometimes it means we care enough not to continue hurting one another.

I still miss her.

I miss the laughter, the ridiculous adventures, the conversations, and the comfort of having someone who felt like a sister. I have other wonderful friends, and I am grateful for them. But each friendship occupies its own space in the heart. One person cannot simply be replaced by another.

I also love my partner. I value the life we are building, the ways he has tried to understand me, and the stability and love we share. Loving him does not erase my grief, just as grieving my friendship does not diminish my love for him.

Perhaps this separation is what is healthiest for all of us right now. I do not know. It hurts.

Maybe one day my friend and I will be able to reconnect in a different way—with healthier boundaries, greater understanding, and less pain. Maybe our friendship will return in a new form. Or perhaps its purpose in my life has already been fulfilled.

I do not know.

What I am learning is that grief does not always mean we made the wrong decision. Sometimes grief simply means the relationship mattered.

Boundaries do not cancel love. Distance does not erase history. And choosing peace does not mean that the person on the other side of the boundary has become our enemy.

For now, I can love my friend without trying to fix everything. I can love my partner without pretending that losing my friendship does not hurt (still working on that one). And I can love myself enough to recognize when a relationship—no matter how meaningful—has become too painful to continue in the same way.

Some people leave our lives completely. Others remain in a quiet corner of our hearts, still loved, even when they no longer walk beside us.

Perhaps God is not asking me to choose between them. Perhaps He is simply teaching me that love can remain, even when relationships have to change.

Comments


Let's Keep Bubble-ing!

Life's better when we pop together.

  • YouTube
  • TikTok
  • Facebook
  • Instagram

MaBubble © 2026

bottom of page